{"seen_tasks": [], "seen_proposals": ["proposal-1770839506087186000", "proposal-1770841433818285400", "proposal-1770838025228028100", "proposal-1770839488634160000", "proposal-1770838370589010900", "proposal-1770838353872151700", "proposal-1770840195139233500", "proposal-1770840274368660100", "proposal-1770841468415132800"], "seen_submissions": ["SUB-1771053740141244700", "SUB-1770854240592026600", "SUB-1770854536898346100", "SUB-1770854037173654900", "SUB-1770854367125075900", "SUB-1770854759980066700", "SUB-1770854987291436200", "SUB-1771052215016676300"], "rejected_proposals": ["proposal-1770839506087186000", "proposal-1770841433818285400", "proposal-1770838370589010900", "proposal-1770840274368660100", "proposal-1770838353872151700", "proposal-1770841468415132800"], "rejection_cache": {"proposal-1770838353872151700": "VERDICT: FAIL - No original wish available for assessment", "proposal-1770838370589010900": "VERDICT: FAIL - Incomplete proposal submission - the proposal content appears to be truncated and cuts off mid-sentence, making it impossible to properly assess the technical implementation approach, scope, or alignment with the wish requirements.", "proposal-1770839506087186000": "VERDICT: FAIL - Proposal references incomplete context and appears to be a fragment of a larger conversation. The description contains internal monologue about process steps (\"I need to create a wish first to get the visible_pixel_hash\") rather than a actual proposal content. The scope described (comprehensive Bitcoin wallet system with 8 tasks, Docker deployment, CI/CD) for 1000 sats budget represents an unreasonable scope/budget mismatch.", "proposal-1770840274368660100": "VERDICT: FAIL - Wish not available and proposal appears incomplete/corrupted with template text instead of complete submission", "proposal-1770841433818285400": "VERDICT: FAIL - Missing wish to assess against", "proposal-1770841468415132800": "VERDICT: FAIL - Appears to be joke or parody submission that describes the proposal creation process rather than addressing a genuine technical need."}, "audit_trail": {"proposal-1770838353872151700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770838353872151700", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - No original wish available for assessment", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848360.6587434, "proposal_title": "Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill Implementation", "proposal_budget": 100000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": true, "approvals": 3, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 3/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770838370589010900": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770838370589010900", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Incomplete proposal submission - the proposal content appears to be truncated and cuts off mid-sentence, making it impossible to properly assess the technical implementation approach, scope, or alignment with the wish requirements.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848705.0779724, "proposal_title": "I'll analyze this wish and create a comprehensive plan with logical tasks for implementing the St...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770839488634160000": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770839488634160000", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848797.615463, "proposal_title": "Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill", "proposal_budget": 1000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770839506087186000": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770839506087186000", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Proposal references incomplete context and appears to be a fragment of a larger conversation. The description contains internal monologue about process steps (\"I need to create a wish first to get the visible_pixel_hash\") rather than a actual proposal content. The scope described (comprehensive Bitcoin wallet system with 8 tasks, Docker deployment, CI/CD) for 1000 sats budget represents an unreasonable scope/budget mismatch.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848833.7306728, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for the Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill. Let me break this...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770840195139233500": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770840195139233500", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848854.9937642, "proposal_title": "Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill Implementation", "proposal_budget": 500000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": true, "approvals": 3, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 3/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770840274368660100": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770840274368660100", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Wish not available and proposal appears incomplete/corrupted with template text instead of complete submission", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848868.464183, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for the Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill. Let me analyze th...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770841433818285400": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770841433818285400", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Missing wish to assess against", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848915.9539635, "proposal_title": "Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill", "proposal_budget": 1000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770841468415132800": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770841468415132800", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Appears to be joke or parody submission that describes the proposal creation process rather than addressing a genuine technical need.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770848981.0196524, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for the Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill. Let me break this...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770838025228028100": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770838025228028100", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770849030.0382452, "proposal_title": "Starlight Wallet Authentication Skill", "proposal_budget": 500000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}}, "last_updated": 1771054242.9593272}