{"seen_tasks": [], "seen_proposals": ["proposal-1771142747783644270", "proposal-1771179769004035703", "proposal-1771144340085105566", "proposal-1771105402571295200", "proposal-1771178701123900693", "proposal-1771178417448212160"], "seen_submissions": [], "rejected_proposals": ["proposal-1771142747783644270", "proposal-1771179769004035703", "proposal-1771144340085105566", "proposal-1771105402571295200", "proposal-1771178701123900693", "proposal-1771178417448212160"], "rejection_cache": {"proposal-1771105402571295200": "VERDICT: FAIL - Scope mismatch with original wish (original wish is \"Not available\", making it impossible to verify scope alignment)", "proposal-1771142747783644270": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: **VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements**\n\nThe proposal has fundamental issues:\n\n1. **No wish/requirement provided** - The original request states \"Not available,\" making it impossible to", "proposal-1771144340085105566": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements; appears to be a nonsensical or test submission with mismatched technical title and completely unrelated content (Valentine's gift plan).", "proposal-1771178417448212160": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements", "proposal-1771178701123900693": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot assess proposal legitimacy without the original wish/context (marked as \"Not available\"), making it impossible to verify if the proposal addresses the actual requirements.", "proposal-1771179769004035703": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not meet minimum requirements for a technical proposal; provides no implementation details, no clear scope, and cannot be verified against the original wish which is not available."}, "audit_trail": {"proposal-1771105402571295200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771105402571295200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Scope mismatch with original wish (original wish is \"Not available\", making it impossible to verify scope alignment)", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771178479.4351463, "proposal_title": "Here's your step-by-step plan:", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1771142747783644270": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771142747783644270", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: **VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements**\n\nThe proposal has fundamental issues:\n\n1. **No wish/requirement provided** - The original request states \"Not available,\" making it impossible to", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771178491.3355904, "proposal_title": "Performing one time database migration, may take a few minutes...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1771144340085105566": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771144340085105566", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements; appears to be a nonsensical or test submission with mismatched technical title and completely unrelated content (Valentine's gift plan).", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771178511.3418238, "proposal_title": "Performing one time database migration, may take a few minutes...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1771178417448212160": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771178417448212160", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not address wish requirements", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771178530.207508, "proposal_title": "Performing one time database migration, may take a few minutes...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1771178701123900693": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771178701123900693", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot assess proposal legitimacy without the original wish/context (marked as \"Not available\"), making it impossible to verify if the proposal addresses the actual requirements.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771178731.9115233, "proposal_title": "MAYA Self-Evolution Plan: Autonomous Starlight Agent", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1771179769004035703": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1771179769004035703", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Does not meet minimum requirements for a technical proposal; provides no implementation details, no clear scope, and cannot be verified against the original wish which is not available.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1771179779.7564108, "proposal_title": "Proposal for: MAYA Self-Evolution v2 - This is MAYA's autonomous", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}}, "last_updated": 1771200988.7542336}