{"seen_tasks": [], "seen_proposals": ["proposal-1770513697760749200", "proposal-1770514039518747700", "proposal-1770516915893742700", "proposal-1770520324965525000", "proposal-1770674410279175200", "proposal-1770515575006697800", "proposal-1770519417706933200", "proposal-1770515560032908700", "proposal-1770520009249745300", "proposal-1770518070507043400", "proposal-1770519019852863600", "proposal-1770517450681849700", "proposal-1770516250728930400", "proposal-1770518560861711600", "proposal-1770519694120307800", "proposal-1770519032779679600", "proposal-1770516921949067700", "proposal-1770514096952793200", "proposal-1770519705143592400", "proposal-1770518748801785200", "proposal-1770518743541731500", "proposal-1770514085026700000", "proposal-1770517482182336900"], "seen_submissions": [], "rejected_proposals": ["proposal-1770513697760749200", "proposal-1770519032779679600", "proposal-1770516921949067700", "proposal-1770520009249745300", "proposal-1770518748801785200", "proposal-1770518070507043400", "proposal-1770519019852863600", "proposal-1770518743541731500", "proposal-1770518560861711600", "proposal-1770514096952793200", "proposal-1770514085026700000", "proposal-1770515575006697800", "proposal-1770674410279175200", "proposal-1770519417706933200", "proposal-1770517482182336900", "proposal-1770519705143592400"], "rejection_cache": {"proposal-1770518560861711600": "Audit timed out after 600s", "proposal-1770518748801785200": "Audit timed out after 600s", "proposal-1770518743541731500": "Audit timed out after 600s", "proposal-1770519019852863600": "VERDICT: FAIL - Recursive proposal: just creates another proposal without actual implementation work. The proposal outlines an implementation plan for an AI-Powered Code Review Assistant but does not contain any actual code, configuration files, or technical artifacts that demonstrate real work being done. It's essentially meta-work describing what would be built rather than building it.", "proposal-1770519032779679600": "VERDICT: FAIL - The proposal appears to be a template or example submission rather than a legitimate response to a specific wish request. The original wish is listed as \"Not available,\" and the proposal describes creating a proposal rather than addressing actual requirements.", "proposal-1770519417706933200": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot assess compliance due to missing wish and proposal appears incomplete with debugging content rather than a proper submission", "proposal-1770513697760749200": "VERDICT: FAIL - Unreasonable scope/budget mismatch", "proposal-1770520009249745300": "VERDICT: FAIL - The proposal appears to be incomplete and malformed. It cuts off mid-sentence in Task 3 and contains debugging/testing text that shouldn't be in a formal proposal. The structure suggests this was a failed attempt at creating a proposal rather than a serious submission.", "proposal-1770514085026700000": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: Looking at this proposal for Starlight governance compliance and quality analysis:\n\n**VERDICT: PASS**\n\nThis is a legitimate technical proposal for an AI-powered code review assistant. The proposal sho", "proposal-1770514096952793200": "VERDICT: FAIL - Original wish not available - cannot verify scope alignment or determine if this is actual implementation vs recursive proposal", "proposal-1770519705143592400": "VERDICT: FAIL - Appears to be test/example content or system demonstration rather than a genuine proposal submission", "proposal-1770517482182336900": "Audit timed out after 600s", "proposal-1770518070507043400": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot verify wish intent compliance as original wish is not available for comparison", "proposal-1770515575006697800": "VERDICT: FAIL - Unreasonable scope/budget mismatch", "proposal-1770516921949067700": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: I need to analyze this Starlight governance proposal, but there's a critical issue with the provided information.\n\nThe assessment criteria requires evaluating whether the proposal \"genuinely addresses", "proposal-1770674410279175200": "Audit timed out after 600s"}, "audit_trail": {"proposal-1770518560861711600": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770518560861711600", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Audit timed out after 600s", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770574396.7242506, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1770518748801785200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770518748801785200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Audit timed out after 600s", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770575298.942145, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770518743541731500": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770518743541731500", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Audit timed out after 600s", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770576499.972174, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 50000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770519019852863600": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770519019852863600", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Recursive proposal: just creates another proposal without actual implementation work. The proposal outlines an implementation plan for an AI-Powered Code Review Assistant but does not contain any actual code, configuration files, or technical artifacts that demonstrate real work being done. It's essentially meta-work describing what would be built rather than building it.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577257.8520756, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 100000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": true, "approvals": 3, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 3/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770519032779679600": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770519032779679600", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - The proposal appears to be a template or example submission rather than a legitimate response to a specific wish request. The original wish is listed as \"Not available,\" and the proposal describes creating a proposal rather than addressing actual requirements.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577289.7944183, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me start b...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770519417706933200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770519417706933200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot assess compliance due to missing wish and proposal appears incomplete with debugging content rather than a proper submission", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577303.6242616, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1770513697760749200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770513697760749200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Unreasonable scope/budget mismatch", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577310.1679342, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 1000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770514039518747700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770514039518747700", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577330.4923828, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 5000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770519694120307800": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770519694120307800", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577351.5829875, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 50000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770520009249745300": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770520009249745300", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - The proposal appears to be incomplete and malformed. It cuts off mid-sentence in Task 3 and contains debugging/testing text that shouldn't be in a formal proposal. The structure suggests this was a failed attempt at creating a proposal rather than a serious submission.", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577368.6284542, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me decompo...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770514085026700000": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770514085026700000", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: Looking at this proposal for Starlight governance compliance and quality analysis:\n\n**VERDICT: PASS**\n\nThis is a legitimate technical proposal for an AI-powered code review assistant. The proposal sho", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577407.2151613, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 50000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770514096952793200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770514096952793200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Original wish not available - cannot verify scope alignment or determine if this is actual implementation vs recursive proposal", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577453.341206, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770519705143592400": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770519705143592400", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Appears to be test/example content or system demonstration rather than a genuine proposal submission", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577471.0166955, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1770515560032908700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770515560032908700", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577482.902656, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 50000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770517450681849700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770517450681849700", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770577506.2284281, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 5000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770517482182336900": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770517482182336900", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Audit timed out after 600s", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578120.0841212, "proposal_title": "Proposal for: Build an AI-powered code review assistant that can", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": false}, "proposal-1770518070507043400": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770518070507043400", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Cannot verify wish intent compliance as original wish is not available for comparison", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578128.3718421, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 5000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770520324965525000": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770520324965525000", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578150.9035168, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant Implementation Plan", "proposal_budget": 50000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770515575006697800": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770515575006697800", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "VERDICT: FAIL - Unreasonable scope/budget mismatch", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578198.4524457, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770516915893742700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770516915893742700", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578221.0189452, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 15000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770516921949067700": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770516921949067700", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Analysis produced invalid verdict: I need to analyze this Starlight governance proposal, but there's a critical issue with the provided information.\n\nThe assessment criteria requires evaluating whether the proposal \"genuinely addresses", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578238.1214476, "proposal_title": "I'll create a comprehensive plan for building an AI-powered code review assistant. Let me break t...", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 8, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 1, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "REJECT"}], "reason": "Only 1/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770516250728930400": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770516250728930400", "decision": "APPROVED", "reasoning": "Passed governance audit", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770578276.981437, "proposal_title": "AI-Powered Code Review Assistant", "proposal_budget": 5000000, "confidence_score": 7, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": false, "approvals": 2, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "REJECT"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 2/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}, "proposal-1770674410279175200": {"proposal_id": "proposal-1770674410279175200", "decision": "REJECTED", "reasoning": "Audit timed out after 600s", "auditor_signature": "starlight-autonomous-agent", "timestamp": 1770675325.2724917, "proposal_title": "Proposal for: Hi GC,", "proposal_budget": 1000, "confidence_score": 10, "peer_review_required": true, "consensus_result": {"has_consensus": true, "approvals": 3, "total_auditors": 3, "threshold": 0.67, "auditor_decisions": [{"id": "auditor_tech", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_budget", "decision": "APPROVE"}, {"id": "auditor_semantic", "decision": "APPROVE"}], "reason": "Only 3/3 auditors approved (threshold: 0.67)"}}}, "last_updated": 1770682207.0809}